Madness rides the star wind.
Register (free)
Grab Twitter Feed: Latewire / Coughlin
Username: Password: NVR4GET
«· Previous Article || Next Article ·»
The Mac Pro is a Silly POS

Daniel Roe
Poster: Daniel Roe @ Sat Jun 26, 2010 1:19 pm

The Mac Pro (not to be confused with the similarly-named "Macbook Pro") is probably the one Apple product that you haven't heard of, as they haven't released a commercial overhyping it in about four years.

Like the Macbook Pro is supposedly just a Macbook with better specs, the Mac Pro is supposed to be an Apple desktop with better upgradability and specs than the Mac Mini or iMac. In those respects, the Mac Pro is still better. However, Apple has been steadily reducing the frequency at which it updates the Mac Pro, which has lead the products current irrelevance.

Unfortunately, even as the Mac Pros on the shelves age, their price tag does not. The current configuration is over 450 days old and has the same price tag as the day it was released onto the market (which was still hefty even then).

It's my contention that the reason Apple is having a hard time keeping the Mac Pro a decent product is because they've made it something that it shouldn't be: A custom form-factor albatross that nobody buys. This is not a Mac Mini, or an iMac. Nor is it a f**king cube. It's a bulky PC workstation that's supposed to have excellent price/performance in exchange for desk real estate. Instead, Apple's insistance of form over function has resulted in neglect of the line and has made it into a sleek-looking overpriced dinosaur.

The Mac Pro started out as a computer that was CHEAPER than a homebuilt alternative with the same specs. That's why I bought one. Todays Mac Pro is an overpriced over-customized rip-off that even Dell and HP can trounce on price/performance.

The following is something I trolled on a mac fanboy forum... for some reason they agreed:

Once you realize--I mean really realize--that a computer is just a bunch of parts, most of which are not special in any way (and are usually similar in quality), you really get annoyed with brand loyalty.

The difference between the Mac Pro and all other Macs is JUST that it's the only Mac that ignores (or should ignore) form factor.

You pay extra for the portability of the Laptops and the desk-space economization of the Mac Mini or the iMac. However, for the Mac Pro, the only distinguishing characteristic should be PRICE.

Mac Pros use (or should use) STANDARD FORM FACTOR parts, and therefore should be the LOWEST PRICE/PERFORMANCE ratio of the macs, not the highest. They are easy to assemble and use STANDARD parts.

The iMac/Mac Mini have an excuse for being expensive (even though they're not): they use extremely customized parts to fit into their small form factor. The Mac Pro does not. Economics of scale dictate the Mac Pro should be updated more frequently and should be of a higher value (ignoring aesthetics).

IMO, the fact that the Mac Pro isn't being updated and is still using old parts (and thus a worse value) is due to Apples over-customization of the motherboard and case components.

The "New" Mac Pro should have as few custom parts as possible. They should use inexpensive, mass-produced yet high quality components that are already on the market (or at least as much of them as possible). No more gigantic grey case fans, just use a standard 120MM. No more stupid aluminum cages that make it a bitch to swap out the CPU, just an empty box with the mobo screwed to the side-wall and case fans in the back. No more ridiculous [UNRELIABLE] PSU with no label on it, just cut a deal with Thermaltake for an all black 1.5KWatt monster.

Take a standard high-end Intel motherboard, tack on some EFI and design the case around it. Duct tape the thing together and sell it at a reasonable price. You could even stuff it inside a brushed aluminum case with an apple sticker on the side and call it good.

The hilarious part that fanboys don't get is: Apple's parts are lower quality than the consumer computer component market (like stuff out of newegg) that sells for a fraction of the cost. Apple uses SH*T hard drives (Maxtor/hitachi) and SH*T RAM. They use THE WORST DVD burners (Sony). Their video cards are buggy/crappy (Radeon 2600) and outdated. Even their "custom" looking components have mass failure like their PSUs. And by the way, they charge more for it.

It's not entirely their fault. Apple's painted themselves into a corner by making these "sleek" formfactors that require custom parts. The more customized the parts, the smaller the scale of fabrication, and therefore the higher the price to produce and to develop (per unit). It also costs more to engineer (or re-engineer, as they often do), on top of re-certifying everything at every step through the FCC. Their custom cases and PSUs have to be run through the regulators with practically each new revision. I'm suggesting they abandon that model for the Mac Pro and just make an "unsexy" 'PC-style' high-quality, high-value box. It's what pro-sumers really want (high-power/quality, low price), abandons the "Sleekness" that is really extraneous to professionals, and has very little cost to create new revisions.

Keywords: Mac  Apple  Mac Pro  Steve Jobs  Vikings 
Comments: 1  •  Post Comment  •  Share Share Top
DeadcowX Mon Jul 05, 2010 9:08 am
I too, share your pain.
«· Previous Article || Next Article ·»

Not working? Try this.
Bio: Daniel Roe
User avatar
Site Admin

Cake City


Daniel is Medical Resident from the southwest US. Prior to medicine, he worked in IT as a consultant, programmer, web designer/developer, and technician.

Health, music, economics, libertarianism, computers

Best Of Latewire
- 3rd Party Payer: How Gov't Made Healthcare Unaffordable
- Is Russia behind the global terrorist epidemic?
- Intern Hell
- S&P's Torrid Love Affair With The Government
- Green Subsidies Destroying Energy Market & Environment
- Why Economic Stimulus Doesn't Work (Latewire Original Video)
- The Season of Reason
- Happy Holidays from your pals at Latewire
- The Healthcare Disaster and Why Obamacare Will Make It Worse
- Video: Interest Rates, The Fed, and History Repeating
- Urban agriculture : Planning your vegetable garden part V
- Urban Agriculture : Planning your Vegetable Garden part IV
- Why The Government Wont Rescue The Dollar
- How the US Government Is Destroying the Dollar -Latewire Vid
- Governing Crazy: Broken Minds & Alcohol
- Urban Agriculture : planning your vegetable garden part III
- Urban Agriculture : Planning Your Vegetable Garden part II
- Urban agriculture for self-reliance : garden planning pt 1
- Why Bailouts Are Stupid (Illustrated Version)
- The Great Depression II, The Making of
- MySpace: A Place for The Damned. Part 1
- Happy Birthday, Latewire! I wrote you a song.
- The Worst Movie Ever!
- Best Long Island Iced Tea EVER
- Everyone loves a top 10 list.
- The Good Ol' Days
- I got your subject right here:
- Male members must represent, like you didn't know.
- Photo Radar: An Extravagant Way To Screw Ourselves
- The Inadequacy of Hope
- TV Companies WANT YOU... to Pirate
- The Gettin' Place
- 46 & ***
- The White Whale

Top 15 Keywords
- Alcohol (12)
- Apple (18)
- Bailouts (31)
- Bernanke (11)
- Economics (27)
- Food (22)
- Goth (13)
- History (12)
- Mac (12)
- Music (23)
- Obama (15)
- Poetry (19)
- Poison (11)
- Slavery (12)
- Snakes (29)

- Latewire Latewear-Shirts&Stuff
- Snatchies Underthings
- Grief Brothers Band
Our Parked Domains:
- Latewire Video
- Poison-Free Diet
- Inflation Hell
- Policy Horn(DUPE)
- Policy Walk(DUPE)
- Policy Reader(DUPE)
- Faux Future(DUPE)
- Scarewire(DUPE)
- Urban Agriculture: The Road to Self-Reliance
- Urban Agriculture: The Road to Self-Reliance(DUPE)
- Urban Agriculture: The Road to Self-Reliance(DUPE)
- Urban Agriculture: The Road to Self-Reliance(DUPE)
- Interview With Dr. LSD

© 2008